I’ll start with the bad news… If you follow me on Instagram, you may have already seen this disaster:
Yup, that’s right folks: the special, gorgeous sock that I knit on before my wedding and during my honeymoon does not fit. It fit as a cuff, it fit as a partial leg, but with the longer-than-usual leg length, the less-elastic-than-usual fiber content (BFL instead of Merino), and the smaller-than-usual needle size (US 0 instead of US 1), it just does not have enough stretch to make it over my gigantic arches and heel. The combination of tightly-knit stockinette and less elastic wool spelled disaster for this sock, even though I added more stitches (68 vs usual 60). I’m considering this a (hard) lesson in the difference in sock yarns. While I was (and still am) excited to try sock yarn made from a longwool breed (I’m hoping the socks will hold up better over time), I now know I need to take the elasticity of the stitch pattern into account. Here are three things I could have done (coulda, woulda, shoulda) to avoid this problem:
- Knit a swatch. I might have knit one, but it was probably tiny, and I really don’t remember if I did or not. So knit a big swatch, in the round, and get a good feel for the fabric and its stretchiness (in addition to figuring out how many stitches to cast on).
- Knit the cuff and leg on larger needles than the heel/foot/toe. In general, I want the foot/sole of the sock to be super snug but the cuff/leg could use some extra elasticity.
- Continue the cuff ribbing all the way down the leg. The difference in stretchiness between the ribbed cuff and the plain stockinette leg is pretty amazing. Basically, if I had knit the leg of this thing with almost any ribbed stitch pattern, I bet it would have fit.
So there you have it, folks. Learn from my mistakes, please! The sock is now in time out until I have the fortitude to face frogging it.
Fiasco De-constructed:
Since sock weather is swiftly approaching, I grabbed an already-in-progress sock to continue working on while I figure out what to do with the BFL pair. (Don’t worry, this one fits.)
Sweet Codex Shawl:
Because I needed a win, and because I have a wedding to attend in October, I cast on a simple shawl in one of my favorite yarns, using a tried-and-true pattern. The yarn is the incomparable Codex (52% silk, 48% BFL) and the pattern is the Sweet November Knit Shawl designed by Caryl Pierre. It’s mindless and soothing and just the thing right now.
Sweet Companion:
I tried and did not like the hat pattern I mentioned a couple of weeks ago. So instead, I’m designing my own hat to accompany the Honey Cowl I plan to knit with the rest of this yarn. I think it’s going to make a pretty snazzy set, if I do say so myself.
Tarnished Yak:

BMFA Yak/Silk fiber on my Jenkins Aegean.
I’m making slow-but-steady progress on my Jenkins Fall SAL spin. My goal is to spin 2 oz by the end of September. I have quite a ways to go yet…
Seaglass:

Miss Babs Merino/Silk in Seaglass on my Enid Ashcroft Mini.
I’ve decided that bringing an itty bitty Turkish spindle to work is totally acceptable behavior. It sits on my desk and I give it a flick every now and again while I’m waiting for something on the computer to load or while my office mate is chatting. Even if I don’t spin anything, seeing it there makes me happy. As you can see by all the yarn in the temporary cop (wrapped around the shaft), spinning during those little idle moments can add up!
Phew! That WIP roundup has been a long time coming. I hope you’ve been making progress on things, as well! Check out more WIPs at Tamis Amis.
You have simply too much going on my friend. I am sorry that your sock didn’t fit, that yarn is so gorgeous. But with all your other projects, it’s not like you are going to be bored. Happy knitting!
LikeLike
Oh noes! That’s the worst.
LikeLike
Ah! That’s happened to me too! Same exact story, but I didn’t realize until both were finished. Those socks sit unloved in a drawer, I hope to gift them to someone someday. That handspun is looking gorgeous! You have been a productive knitter too.
LikeLike
Bummer about the sock! I love the yarn of the hat:)
LikeLike
Well maybe the first sock was just like a big swatch 😉 looks gorgeous! It’ll be a lovely pair of socks.
LikeLike
That is a heartbreaking sock photo. But I love the shawl! It is simple, but it looks kind of striking and is a little different than many of the shawls I’ve done, so now I kind of want to try it. Especially if you say it’s easy.
LikeLike
Oh no! Your lovely wedding sock is heartbreaking to look at. Will you reknit it anytime soon?
LikeLike
I will, I might try doing toe up to at least learn something new.
LikeLike
Oh dear. What a shame about the sock! I love BFL yarn and have used it quite a lot in socks. Perhaps if you had used 2.25mm needles it would have worked? Your other projects look lovely!
LikeLike
Pingback: Blog Hop: Creative Process | Woolen Diversions
Pingback: Sock Sucker | Woolen Diversions